Skip to main content

Blogs · Solutions

Raising menu prices in a year when guests are spending less

· Updated

In a slow year, raise prices dish by dish instead of across the whole menu. Cost every dish at today's prices, move the items that lose money and the ones guests do not compare, hold the two or three prices everyone remembers, and watch the guest count for a month before the next step. A small increase done with care is safer than a large one done once.

The pressure is real on both sides of the bill, so it helps to see it plainly first.

Costs are up and guests are careful

Restaurants Canada's first-quarter report for 2026 found 36% of operators operating at a loss or breaking even. Among the pressures, 91% cited food costs and 87% labour. On the other side of the bill, 54% reported fewer guests, and 69% said customers were dining out less because of affordability.

That is the difficulty in one paragraph. The price has to rise, and the guest has less room for it. The answer is to be exact about where the increase goes.

Cost every dish before you change a price

Take the current invoices and cost each plate: every ingredient at this month's price, the garnish, the oil, the packaging for takeout. Most owners find that a few dishes carry the menu and a few lose money on every order.

Put that beside how often each dish sells. A popular dish with a thin margin is where a small increase earns the most. A dish that sells twice a week and loses money should leave the menu.

Hold the prices guests remember

Guests carry two or three of your prices in their heads: the signature dish, the lunch special, the coffee or the pint. Those are the prices they compare with the place down the street. Keep them steady as long as you can.

The dishes around them are judged less closely. Sides, starters, desserts, premium versions and drinks made in-house can carry more of the increase without changing how the restaurant feels.

Try the menu before the price

Some of the gap can close without a price change. Review portion sizes against what comes back on the plate. Rework a recipe around an ingredient whose cost has run away. Remove slow dishes that tie up stock and prep time.

Then look at the menu itself. Where a dish sits on the page and how it is described changes how often it is ordered. Give the dishes with the best margin the best positions.

Move in small steps and keep one door open

Change a handful of prices at a time and leave a month between rounds. If guests react, you will know which change caused it, and you can reverse one price instead of reprinting the menu.

Keep at least one way to eat with you that still feels affordable: a lunch plate, a smaller size, a set meal. A guest who is watching their spending should find a reason to stay a regular.

Prepare the team and do not apologise

Tell the staff before the menu changes, with one honest sentence they can use if a guest asks. A note on the menu about rising costs draws attention to the increase and tells guests nothing new.

Update every place the price appears on the same day: the printed menu, the menu boards, the website and Google. A guest who sees one price online and another at the counter remembers it. For Sam's Grill, every store's menu boards are changed from one place.

Watch four numbers for a month

Guest count, average spend per guest, the mix of dishes ordered, and food cost against sales. If guests hold and spend rises, the change worked. If guests hold and they move to cheaper dishes, the increase was on the wrong items. If the guest count falls, reverse the last change first.

Pricing is part of the weekly work we do with owners, alongside revenue and operations. The numbers above belong in front of you every week.

Common questions

How often can a restaurant raise its prices?

Small changes a few times a year are easier on guests than one large change. Tie each round to your own costing, and leave enough time between rounds to read the guest count.

Should I tell guests that prices are going up?

There is no need to announce it. Make sure the team can answer plainly if asked, and that the price is the same everywhere a guest might look. Regulars forgive a higher price more easily than a surprise at the till.

Should delivery app prices match the dine-in menu?

Cost delivery as its own menu, because the platform's fee and the packaging change the margin on every dish. Check your agreement with the platform before setting different prices, and say so on your own website if delivery costs more.

Sources

The work behind this article

Talk to us about your restaurant

Book a call