Skip to main content

Blogs · Marketing

What to do when a guest threatens a one-star review to get a refund

· Updated

Decide the refund on what happened at the table, as if the review had never been mentioned. If the complaint is fair, put it right. If it is not, say no politely. Either way, do not trade money for a review or for silence, and keep every message.

A different case is a stranger who never ate with you, posts or promises a run of one-star ratings and asks for payment to stop. That is an extortion scam. Google has a form for it, and its advice is not to pay.

Separate the complaint from the threat

Often the message comes from a real guest with a real grievance who has learned that mentioning Google gets a faster answer. The grievance may be fair even when the delivery is not.

So ask two questions in order. Did something go wrong, by your own standards. And what would you have offered if the guest had asked nicely. That offer is your answer. The threat should not raise it or lower it.

Answer the complaint, and leave the review out of it

Reply in writing, the same day, and do not mention the review at all. If you are refunding: "I am sorry about the wait and the cold mains on Saturday. I have refunded the two dishes to your card today. I hope you will give us another try."

If you are not: "I have spoken to the team and checked the bill. The dishes were served as described on the menu and were eaten, so I am not able to refund them. I am sorry the evening was not what you hoped for, and I would be glad to talk it through by phone."

Neither message bargains. Both would read well if the guest posted a screenshot, which you should assume they will.

Why the refund cannot be a trade

It is tempting to write "we will refund you if you take the review down". Google's policy prohibits it. Merchants may not "Offer incentives – such as payment, discounts, free goods and/or services - in exchange for posting any review or revision or removal of a negative review."

There is a practical reason as well. A restaurant known to pay for silence gets asked again.

If the review goes up anyway

A one-star review from a guest who did eat with you describes a real visit, and Google is unlikely to remove it for being unfair. It tells owners not to report a review because they disagree with it or dislike it.

Reply to it calmly. State what happened and what you offered, without calling it blackmail and without private details: "We are sorry the visit disappointed you. We looked into it the next morning and offered a refund for the two dishes." A future guest reading both sides can judge.

When it is a scam, report it to Google and do not pay

Google describes the pattern: "a sudden increase in 1-star and 2-star reviews on your Google Business Profile, followed by someone demanding money, goods, or services in exchange for removing the negative reviews". Its instructions are plain. "Do not engage with or pay the malicious individuals. This can encourage further attempts and doesn't guarantee the removal of reviews."

Collect evidence at once: screenshots of every demand showing the date, time and sender, links to each suspicious review, any names, numbers or usernames, and when the reviews and the demand first appeared. Submit it through Google's merchant extortion report form, linked from its help page on extortion scams. Google says it investigates and tells you the result. The form is only for cases where someone has demanded money or favours from you directly.

When it becomes a police matter

Section 346 of the Criminal Code says a person commits extortion who, "without reasonable justification or excuse and with intent to obtain anything, by threats, accusations, menaces or violence induces or attempts to induce any person" to do anything.

A guest with a real complaint who says they will write an honest review is in a different position from a stranger demanding payment. Where a particular message falls is a question for the police or a lawyer. We are a marketing agency and cannot answer it. What you can do is keep the evidence complete and unedited, so that whoever you ask has everything.

Common questions

Should I refund the guest to avoid the bad review?

Refund if the complaint is fair, and for that reason only. A refund given to prevent a review teaches the guest, and their friends, that the threat works. It also does not stop them from posting.

Should I tell the guest that their message is extortion?

No. It turns a complaint into a fight and gives them a line to quote. Answer the complaint, keep the messages, and take advice from a lawyer if you believe a line has been crossed.

What if the threat comes by phone or in person?

Write down the date, time and what was said straight away, and ask the guest to put the complaint in an email so you can look into it properly. Google's form asks for evidence of the demand, and a written record is far easier to act on.

Sources

Talk to us about your restaurant

Book a call