A restaurant cannot delete a Google review. You can report it, and Google removes it only when it breaks Google's content policies: a review with no real visit behind it, one posted by a competitor, or one from a current or former employee. If the report is refused you have one appeal.
After that, three things remain. A calm public reply, a complaint to the Competition Bureau where the reviews look organised, and a lawyer where a statement is untrue and doing real damage.
What Google counts as fake
Google's policy says a review "should reflect an actual experience with a business, and be genuine and unbiased". It lists what will be removed: content "not based on a real experience", reviews "paid for, directly or in kind", content posted from several accounts by one person, and content posted "on a competitor's place or business to undermine that business' or product's reputation".
A conflict of interest is also a breach. Google names "current or former employment", contractual relationships, industry competitors and family relationships. A review from a cook you let go last month falls here, whatever it says.
What Google will leave up
A harsh review of a real visit stays. Google tells owners not to report a review because they disagree with it or dislike it, and says it "doesn't get involved in conflict between businesses and customers".
So a guest who waited forty minutes and exaggerates it to two hours is unlikely to be removed. A reviewer describing a dish you have never served, on a day you were closed, is the kind of case worth reporting.
How to report it
Open your Business Profile, select Read reviews, and next to the review select Report. Choose the reason that fits and send. Google says evaluation "typically takes several days".
Track the report in Google's Reviews Management Tool. It shows one of three statuses: decision pending, reviewed with no policy violation found, or escalated. If no violation is found you can "submit a one-time appeal", for up to ten reviews at once, and the result comes by email.
Because the appeal can be used once, prepare before you send it. Check the booking book, the till records and the staff rota for the date in the review. Write down what shows there was no visit, or who the reviewer is to you. Name the policy line the review breaks.
Reply while you wait
The review is public for as long as Google takes, so answer it. Your reply is public too, and the reviewer is notified. Write for the next guest reading it.
Something like this is enough: "We have looked through our bookings and bills and cannot find this visit. If we have missed it, please write to us at our email address with the date and we will look again." It states your position, accuses no one and leaves the door open. Google's own guidance for replies is "Never share a reviewer's private information or engage in personal attacks."
What Canadian law adds
The Competition Act treats it as reviewable conduct when a person, to promote a business interest, "makes a representation to the public that is false or misleading in a material respect". The Competition Bureau has said that anyone who suspects a fake review, or an organised effort to manipulate ratings, should report it through the Bureau's complaint form. A complaint is a report to a regulator. The Bureau decides what it investigates, and the review stays on Google unless Google removes it.
A review that states something untrue and damaging about you may also be a matter for defamation law. That is a question for a lawyer, who can tell you whether acting on it is worth the cost. We are a marketing agency and do not advise on it.
What makes it worse
Do not answer fake reviews with your own. The same Google policy and the same Act apply to you. In January 2024 the Competition Bureau warned that anyone who writes, or permits, reviews that mislead consumers could be liable, and that employees who cannot disclose their connection should not post.
Do not offer the reviewer anything to take it down. Google prohibits merchants from offering incentives "in exchange for posting any review or revision or removal of a negative review".
Common questions
How long does Google take to remove a fake review?
Google says evaluation typically takes several days. An appeal adds more time, and Google gives no figure for it. Plan for the review to be visible for a while and reply to it in the meantime.
Can I pay a company to remove Google reviews?
The reporting and appeal tools are free and the decision belongs to Google. Anyone selling guaranteed removal has no more say in that decision than you do. Ask what they would do that you cannot do yourself.
Does Google ever remove real reviews by mistake?
Yes. Google says its automated spam detection "may also mistakenly remove legitimate reviews", and tells owners to contact support when that happens. It is one reason a sudden drop in review count is worth checking.
Sources
- Google Business Profile Help: Prohibited and restricted content
- Google Business Profile Help: Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile
- Google Business Profile Help: Tips to get more reviews (includes tips for review replies)
- Google Business Profile Help: Manage customer reviews
- Competition Bureau: Online reviews posted by employees, businesses could be liable (18 January 2024)
- Competition Act, section 74.01 (Justice Laws)